Tetairoa McMillan NFL Draft 2025: Scouting Report For Arizona WR

Arizona’s Tetairoa McMillan is a big-bodied playmaker with elite ball-tracking skills and contested-catch dominance. His size, strong hands, and route-running make him a reliable target at all levels. While he lacks top-end speed, his versatility and ability to create mismatches make him a valuable NFL prospect. Continue reading to learn all about his scouting report and where he might go in the 2025 NFL Draft.

HT: 6041
WT: 219
HAND: 1000
ARM: 3268
40: 4.55

Tetairoa McMillan NFL Draft Scouting Report

Tetairoa McMillan is a big-bodied, highly skilled wide receiver with a rare combination of size, ball-tracking ability, and playmaking versatility. With his ability to dominate in contested catch situations, create mismatches at multiple alignments, and produce after the catch, he projects as a reliable target at all three field levels. This could potentially translate to fantasy football production. While he lacks elite top-end speed, his strong hands, advanced route-running, and knack for making big plays make him an immediate contributor at the next level.

Strengths:

• Catch Radius & Ball Skills: McMillan’s hands are a quarterback’s dream—large, soft, and reliable. He excels at tracking the ball in the air and adjusting to off-target throws easily. His 60% contested catch rate in 2024 highlights his ability to win jump balls and back-shoulder fades.
• Positional Versatility: Arizona deployed him everywhere—outside as an X-receiver, in the slot, and even tight to the formation. This flexibility creates mismatches against smaller corners or slower linebackers.
• Route Running Nuance: McMillan’s route tree is solid for a big receiver. He thrives on slants, crossers, and deep posts, using subtle tempo changes and head fakes to create separation. His whip routes and in-cuts are particularly lethal.
• Red Zone Dominance: His size and leaping ability make him a matchup problem near the goal line. McMillan’s knack for high-pointing the ball and boxing out defenders is reminiscent of elite NFL red-zone threats.
• YAC Potential: While not a shifty, tackle-breaking machine, McMillan’s balance and long strides allow him to pick up chunk yards after the catch. He forced 25 missed tackles in 2024 alone.

Areas for Improvement:

• Release vs. Press Coverage: McMillan can struggle against physical corners who get their hands on him at the line. His release package lacks consistency, and he sometimes takes wide angles to avoid contact, limiting his ability to stack defenders vertically.
• Top-End Speed: While his 4.55 40-time is solid for his size, McMillan isn’t a true deep burner. Defenses that play off-coverage can limit his ability to stretch the field unless he refines his route-running deception.
• Physicality & Blocking: McMillan has the frame to dominate smaller defensive backs, but he doesn’t always play to his size. His blocking effort is adequate, but he lacks the aggression to move defenders consistently in the run game.
• Route Polish: While advanced for a college receiver, McMillan occasionally wastes motion in his breaks. Sharpening his footwork and transitions could elevate him from good to elite as a separator.

Conclusion:

Tetairoa McMillan is a rare talent—a big, smooth receiver with the tools to dominate at the next level. If he refines his release and adds polish to his game, he could become a perennial Pro Bowler and a cornerstone for an NFL passing attack. For now, he’s a plug-and-play starter with superstar upside.

McMillan profiles as a Day 1 starter with WR1 potential in the right system. His blend of size, hands, and route-running savvy draws comparisons to a leaner Mike Evans or a more fluid Drake London. He’s best suited for an offense that values a big-bodied target who can win in the red zone and move the chains on third downs. Teams with a strong-armed quarterback—think Josh Allen or Justin Herbert—could unlock his full potential by trusting him on 50/50 balls and deep shots. While he may need time to adjust to the physicality of NFL corners, his high floor and tantalizing ceiling make him a lock for the first round, likely in the top 15 picks.

Ideal fits for McMillan would be a team like the New England Patriots—a true X-receiver to pair with a young QB like Drake Maye, giving their offense a go-to perimeter threat. Even the New York Jets to be opposite Garrett Wilson, McMillan’s size would complement the speedster, creating a dynamic duo for Aaron Rodgers. Or the Tampa Bay Buccaneers to be a long-term successor to Mike Evans, bringing a similar skill set to Baker Mayfield’s vertical attack.

Round Grade: Mid 1st-Early 2nd Round

Stats: Per Sports Reference

Trending Now

Top 10 Rookie Tight Ends for 2025

Top 10 RB Performances of the Season

5 Dynasty Buy-Low Targets