Why Shedeur Sanders Fell in 2025 Draft & Fantasy Outlook
Shedeur Sanders, once projected as a top-10 pick, shocked the NFL world when he slid to the fifth round of the 2025 NFL Draft, selected by the Cleveland Browns. This article dives into the reasons behind his dramatic draft fall and evaluates his fantasy football outlook for the 2025 season. More importantly, offering insights for fantasy football managers looking to draft the former Colorado star. Continue reading this Shedeur Sanders 2025 NFL Draft breakdown and his fantasy outlook for 2025.
Why Did Shedeur Sanders Fall in the 2025 NFL Draft?
Sanders’ slide was a combination of on-field concerns, off-field perceptions, and draft dynamics. Below, we break down the key factors that led NFL teams to pass on the high-profile quarterback.
On-Field Performance and Scouting Concerns
While Sanders posted impressive college stats—14,347 passing yards and 134 touchdowns—NFL scouts identified several limitations:
Limited Physical Tools: Sanders’ arm strength was deemed “good but not great,” with inconsistent velocity on shorter throws. He also lacked the elite athleticism of dual-threat QBs like Jalen Milroe.
Pocket Presence Issues: He took 94 sacks in his final two college seasons, partly due to Colorado’s weak offensive line but also his tendency to hold the ball too long.
Scheme Questions: Colorado’s simplified offense raised concerns about his ability to transition to complex NFL systems quickly.
Pre-Draft Decisions: Opting out of competitive events like the combine and Shrine Bowl limited his exposure, and his pro day showed mixed results.
Off-Field Perceptions and Personality
Sanders’ larger-than-life persona, shaped by his father Deion Sanders and a high-profile lifestyle, created a polarizing image:
Leadership Doubts: Some teams viewed Sanders as “brash” or “arrogant” in interviews, questioning his ability to lead an NFL locker room.
Brand Over Football: His involvement in a rap song, reality TV, and endorsements led some to question his focus on football.
Deion’s Influence: Deion Sanders’ outspoken comments, including guaranteeing a top-five pick and criticizing teams, were seen as overbearing. The lack of a traditional agent, with his mother Pilar taking an agent-like role, added complexity.
Additionally, an anonymous NFL coach criticized Sanders’ body language and perceived entitlement. Overall, this highlights how off-field impressions impacted his draft stock.
Draft Context and Team Priorities
The 2025 quarterback class was considered weak. However, Sanders was overtaken by five other quarterbacks, including Cam Ward (No. 1 overall) and Jaxson Dart (No. 25). Key draft dynamics included:
Competition: Teams prioritized QBs with fewer perceived risks or different skill sets, like Milroe’s athleticism or Dart’s pocket presence.
Team Needs: Free agency moves (e.g., Raiders signing Geno Smith) reduced the demand for drafted QBs.
Late-Round Value: The Browns saw Sanders as a developmental prospect. Ultimately, this was a low-risk chance and could be a massive value as a fifth round pick.
Shedeur Sanders’ Fantasy Football Outlook for 2025
For fantasy football managers, Sanders’ fifth-round selection to the Cleveland Browns creates an intriguing but uncertain outlook for the 2025 season. Here’s what to expect and how to approach him in drafts.
Current Situation with the Browns
Sanders joins a Browns team with an established quarterback in Deshaun Watson, who remains under contract. This likely positions Sanders as a backup or developmental QB in 2025, limiting his immediate fantasy relevance:
Depth Chart: Watson’s presence means Sanders is unlikely to start unless an injury occurs or Watson underperforms significantly.
Offensive Fit: Cleveland’s offense, under Kevin Stefanski, emphasizes play-action and a strong run game, which could suit Sanders’ accurate deep ball if he sees the field.
Weapons: Sanders would benefit from receivers like Amari Cooper (if re-signed) and David Njoku, plus a solid offensive line, though the Browns’ conservative scheme may cap his passing volume.
Fantasy Football Value
Sanders’ fantasy football value in 2025 hinges on his role. Here’s a breakdown for different league formats:
Redraft Leagues: Sanders is a late-round flier (QB3 or lower) in standard leagues. He’s only worth rostering if Watson struggles or Sanders wins a training camp battle, which seems unlikely.
Dynasty Leagues: Sanders is a more appealing pick in dynasty formats, where his long-term upside makes him a mid-to-late-round target. Overall, his college production and confidence suggest he could develop into a starter by 2026.
Superflex Leagues: In superflex or 2QB leagues, Sanders’ value rises slightly due to his potential to see snaps. All in all, I’d consider him a QB3 with upside if he gets early playing time.
Strengths for Fantasy Football
If Sanders sees the field, his skill set offers fantasy upside:
Accuracy and Touch: Sanders’ college tape showed pinpoint accuracy on deep throws, which could translate to chunk plays in the NFL.
Poise Under Pressure: Despite taking sacks, he showed composure in high-pressure situations, a plus for fantasy in late-game scenarios.
Motivation: Coaches like Sean Payton have noted Sanders’ “chip on his shoulder” post-draft, suggesting he’ll work hard to prove doubters wrong.
Risks for Fantasy
Several factors could limit Sanders’ 2025 fantasy production:
Limited Playing Time: As a backup, Sanders may not see meaningful snaps unless Watson is injured or benched.
Learning Curve: His adjustment to NFL defenses and Cleveland’s system could lead to early struggles if he plays.
Low Rushing Upside: Unlike mobile quarterbacks, Sanders’ lack of rushing production might cap his fantasy football ceiling.
Draft Strategy for 2025
In most redraft leagues, Sanders is a waiver wire watch rather than a draft target. You may end using some FAAB on him after a few weeks or if you’re dealing with injuries. Monitor Browns’ training camp reports and Watson’s performance. In dynasty leagues, draft Sanders in the later rounds (Rounds 10-15) as a stash for future seasons. His ADP is likely to be low due to his draft slide and backup role. Ultimately, this makes him a low-risk, high-reward pick for patient fantasy football managers.
Fantasy Tip: Pair Sanders with a reliable QB1 or QB2 in dynasty leagues to cover his developmental year, banking on his potential to emerge as a starter by 2026. Ultimately, his dynasty fantasy football outlook is interesting as he still has a ton of upside and a great opportunity ahead of him.
Conclusion
Shedeur Sanders’ fall to the fifth round of the 2025 NFL Draft was a mix of on-field limitations, off-field perceptions, and a weak quarterback class that saw teams prioritize other prospects. While his immediate fantasy football outlook for 2025 is limited as a Browns backup, his long-term potential makes him an intriguing dynasty stash. Fantasy football managers should keep tabs on his development, as his talent and drive could make him a steal for those who invest early.
Trending Now
