7 Rookie Bust Candidates – Dynasty Fantasy Football (2024)

As we gear up for the 2024 fantasy football season, identifying potential busts among rookie players is crucial for dynasty managers. While the excitement surrounding fresh talent is palpable, not every highly touted prospect lives up to the hype. In this article, we’ll delve into 7 rookie bust candidates who may fail to meet expectations in their inaugural season. By examining their team situations, competition, and potential red flags, we aim to help you avoid costly mistakes in your dynasty fantasy football leagues. Whether it’s due to limited opportunities, challenging team dynamics, or the transition to the NFL level, these rookies might struggle to make an immediate impact in 2024.

7 Rookie Bust Candidates for 2024 Fantasy Football

Every year, building an NFL roster for the future begins at the onset of the league year. Analyzing how new signings and drafted players will fit into their roles keeps both fantasy football enthusiasts and NFL analysts busy throughout the offseason. While some rookies quickly make an impact, others struggle to transition their physical tools into early career success.

In this article, I’ll examine some 2024 rookies who may be buy-low or avoid candidates due to uncertain early outlooks or heavy competition. Additionally, I will assess team situations, potential impacts on fantasy lineups, and whether their skillsets translate to immediate fantasy football production.

WR Brian Thomas Jr., Jacksonville Jaguars

Rookie Brian Thomas Jr. is a big, fast wide receiver poised to see snaps on the outside for the Jaguars. However, his fantasy value is contingent on how many targets Trevor Lawrence can distribute among the team’s assets, including Christian Kirk, Gabriel Davis, Travis Etienne, and Evan Engram. With the Jaguars aiming for a playoff return, Thomas Jr. might find himself in a crowded offense with high expectations. Comparing him to past situations like the Titans’ wide receiver overhaul, Thomas Jr. could face challenges in achieving significant production early in his career.

WR Adonai Mitchell, Indianapolis Colts

Adonai Mitchell’s intriguing size and speed pegged him as a potential WR1 before the draft. Post-Draft Day 2, he joins a Colts team with a run-heavy focus led by Anthony Richardson and Jonathan Taylor, alongside established receivers like Michael Pittman and Josh Downs. Mitchell will start behind these players in an offense that might not prioritize his development immediately, making his fantasy outlook less promising for 2024.

WR Xavier Worthy, Kansas City Chiefs

Heading into the 2024 NFL Draft, one of the best landing spots for a wide receiver was the Kansas City Chiefs. As a result, Xavier Worthy, drafted by the Chiefs, exemplifies a luxury pick for future upside. Known for his speed, Worthy needs to develop his route-running and release skills. With Hollywood Brown and Rashee Rice ahead of him, Worthy’s role in the offense might be limited initially. His value lies in long-term potential rather than immediate fantasy production, making him a deeper stash in dynasty formats.

RB Blake Corum, Los Angeles Rams

Blake Corum joins the Rams as a powerful rusher, but he will start behind Kyren Williams, who has secured the coaching staff’s trust with consistent touches. While Corum possesses talent, his rookie season might be limited to a complementary role. Corum’s fantasy value could grow in future seasons as he adapts to the NFL and potentially takes on a larger role.

TE Ben Sinnott, Washington Commanders

Ben Sinnott joins a Commanders team that added talent at quarterback with Jayden Daniels and wide receiver Luke McCaffrey. However, veterans Terry McLaurin and Jahan Dotson will likely dominate targets, along with new backfield addition Austin Ekeler. Unfortunately, Ekeler was pretty disappointing last year, according to our free fantasy football tools.

Additionally, Sinnott will need time to develop and integrate into the offense. This makes him a long-term project rather than an immediate fantasy contributor. Don’t be afraid to draft him late in your rookie drafts and stash him on your taxi squad if you need to.

QB JJ McCarthy, Minnesota Vikings

With Kirk Cousins out of Minnesota, it was only a matter of time before a new quarterback would get the starting role. JJ McCarthy’s fit with the Vikings is ideal, given the presence of elite receiver Justin Jefferson. Though McCarthy might start behind Sam Darnold, he could take over by season’s end. However, with the Vikings aiming for NFC competition, McCarthy’s leash may be short. His immediate fantasy impact might be limited as he adjusts to the NFL and proves his viability as a starter.

QB Bo Nix, Denver Broncos

Similar to the Vikings, the Broncos needed a new quarterback after losing their starting veteran quarterback. Bo Nix, selected by the Broncos, brings a mature skillset but faces a challenging offensive situation. With limited proven talent outside of Courtland Sutton, Nix will rely on his rushing ability to put together some additional fantasy points. The Broncos’ offensive shortcomings may hamper Nix’s early career success, making him a speculative long-term play in dynasty leagues.

Overall, this 2024 NFL Draft class features many promising talents, some poised for immediate roles and others requiring time to develop. While rookies like Malik Nabers and Marvin Harrison Jr. are set for early targets, others must transform their skillsets to maximize their opportunities. By identifying potential buy-low or avoid candidates, fantasy managers can better strategize for the 2024 season and beyond.

Trending Now

What is a Guillotine League?

Madden 25 ’99 Club’

Dynasty Fantasy Football Rookie ADP

2024 NFL Draft Rankings:

QB | RB | WR | TE | OT | iOL | iDL | EDGE | LB | CB | S

• 2024 NFL Draft Big Board