2025 Dynasty Superflex Rookie Mock Draft (Post-NFL Draft)
With the 2025 NFL Draft behind us, I have gathered 11 experts to join me in a 4-round, Superflex rookie mock draft. Keep in mind, in Superflex leagues, you can start two quarterbacks. However, you don’t have to. Needless to say, quarterbacks are quite valuable in this format. However, with this rookie class, the quarterbacks may be pushed down. With landing spots finalized, let’s look at what the experts say as we prepare you for your upcoming rookie drafts.
- 1.01 Jamie Perog (Going for 2, Fantasy Six Pack, RPO Football Show)
- 1.02 Andrew Vailliencourt (Dynasty War Room Podcast)
- 1.03 Joe DiTullio (The Game Haus)
- 1.04 Brad Rich (Faceoff Sports Network)
- 1.05 Joe Simonetti (Faceoff Sports Network)
- 1.06 Aaron Schill (Faceoff Sports Network)
- 1.07 Ryan Miner (Faceoff Sports Network)
- 1.08 Geoff Lambert (Going for 2)
- 1.09 Dave Heilman (SGPN)
- 1.10 Anthony Cervino (Faceoff Sports Network)
- 1.11 Ali Cook (Fantasy Wildcard Dynasty)
- 1.12 Joe Goodwin (Fantasy in Frames)
Round 1
1.01 Ashton Jeanty, RB, Las Vegas Raiders
Ashton Jeanty is a true three-down workhorse who can dominate touches and stay on the field in any situation. Furthermore, in a class lacking a clear elite QB or WR, landing a dynamic back like Jeanty felt like the safest, highest upside pick. Moreover, his talent and projected workload made him an easy choice at the top. In fact, he’s my overall dynasty RB1 and should already be a consensus top 3 dynasty RB.
1.02 Omarion Hampton, RB, Las Angeles Chargers
Omarion Hampton is a true three-down back that lands in an upper-tier, run-friendly offense under Jim Harbaugh. Consequently, he should quickly — if not immediately — seize the starting job from Najee Harris, who signed a cheap, one-year deal. Furthermore, Hampton has the pass-catching skills to be an elite fantasy asset and, as a result, will get a huge workload.
1.03 Tyler Warren, TE, Indianapolis Colts
Tyler Warren can impact the game in so many ways; for instance, Penn State used him as a tight end and wildcat quarterback. Furthermore, even though the quarterback situation isn’t the greatest, if the Colts can tap into his versatility, he undoubtedly has more value than most other players in the class. Ultimately, in a TE premium league, Warren can rack up the points if used correctly.
1.04 Tetairoa McMillan, WR, Carolina Panthers
Tetairoa McMillan played through an injury during the 2024 season; nevertheless, he still put up 1,309 yards and eight touchdowns. Furthermore, his ability to come down with contested catches makes him the perfect go-to target for Bryce Young. Consequently, expect McMillan to be a red zone monster at the next level with the Carolina Panthers.
1.05 Cam Ward, QB, Tennessee Titans
The 2025 quarterback class, on the other hand, pales in comparison to last year’s. Although the Tennessee Titans aren’t an ideal place for a rookie quarterback, they aren’t exactly void of talent, particularly with the likes of Calvin Ridley, Tyler Lockett, Chigoziem Okonkwo, and Tony Pollard. Moreover, the last time I checked, in the land of superflex, the quarterback is king. Therefore, a quarterback who was first overall with the 1.05? Yes, please and thank you.
1.06 Travis Hunter, WR, Jacksonville Jaguars
In a Superflex draft, I’m happy to have the most talented wide receiver in this draft class fall to me at the 1.06. The only concern might be Brian Thomas Jr., who just had a fantastic rookie campaign. However, this should be a long-term spot where both receivers can thrive. Between the addition of Liam Coen and Trevor Lawrence hopefully taking a leap, this Jaguars offense should be dangerous in 2025 and beyond.
1.07 TreVeyon Henderson, RB, New England Patriots
The New England Patriots built greatly around Drake Maye in the NFL draft. Surprisingly early, they drafted TreVeyon Henderson in the early second round (38th overall). A running back who is fast and elusive, who can catch out of the backfield. Yes, please! While it may take some time for Henderson to surpass Rhamondre Stevenson for the RB1 in New England. However, Henderson has the potential to be the second-best back of this class by season’s end. Don’t sleep on him.
1.08 Quinshon Judkins, RB, Cleveland Browns
Landing in the 8-spot, I knew I would end up with one of the top 6 running backs; however, it was just a matter of which one. Ultimately, I landed on Quinshon Judkins over RJ Harvey and Kaleb Johnson. Specifically, Harvey was someone that I had not scouted much pre-draft, and consequently, I did not have him as a first-round pick.
Because of this, I was afraid to let his situation influence me; therefore, I passed on him. Moreover, I decided against Johnson due to him being a little too one-dimensional, as he had not caught many passes in college.
1.09 Colston Loveland, TE, Chicago Bears
The Bears told us what they think about Colston Loveland, taking him at 10 overall and over Tyler Warren. This is a tough position to find young talent; however, when you do hit, they are impossible to trade for. Furthermore, I love what the Bears are doing there, and we can see the vision of how Loveland would be used.
Additionally, Sam LaPorta was a top 3 Fantasy Football Tight End under Johnson. Consequently, I love the long-term outlook, and I don’t think you are going to have to wait too long for fantasy relevance.
1.10 Emeka Egbuka, WR, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
With Mike Evans and Chris Godwin both still under contract, this might be more of a long-term play with Egbuka. However, the health of both of these wide receivers could give Egbuka plenty of chances to prove himself in year one. In what may appear to be a rough landing spot, I still have high hopes for Baker Mayfield and the likely future WR1 of this Buccaneers offense.
1.11 RJ Harvey, RB, Denver Broncos
Maybe the biggest riser over the draft weekend. Indeed, we did not expect RJ Harvey to be the 5th RB off the board, let alone be drafted in the 2nd round to perhaps the perfect landing spot. Consequently, Harvey is up to my RB5 for this class, and I’m happy to take him from pick 1.08; thus, getting him 2 spots later feels like great value.
Although he is an older prospect, he is one who is sure to have immediate production. Furthermore, the ceiling really is Alvin Kamara 2.0 under coach Sean Payton, and having looked at the depth chart, he’s only competing with the likes of Jaleel McLaughlin and Audric Estime.
1.12 Kaleb Johnson, RB, Pittsburgh Steelers
I have Kaleb Johnson sixth on my big board. Therefore, to get him with the 12th pick, I was ecstatic. Moreover, Kaleb Johnson has done everything right and, consequently, joins a team that vacated 263 rushing attempts and 48 targets (Najee Harris). As a result, Johnson is in a prime position to inherit those opportunities and, ultimately, has immense value as the 12th pick in this draft.
Round 2
2.01 Jaxson Dart, QB, New York Giants
Jaxson Dart is my QB1 in this class due to his fantasy upside; therefore, he is a no-brainer in the 2nd round. In addition, he’s dangerous on designed runs and scrambles, and he consistently keeps his eyes downfield while standing tough in the pocket. Although he may need a year to climb the depth chart, his rushing ability and connection to Malik Nabers suggest that his ceiling is massive.
2.02 Luther Burden III, WR, Chicago Bears
I’m shooting for upside with this pick. Although the offense is crowded, I believe in Luther Burden’s talent. Furthermore, he’s an elite YAC threat that also has good size.
2.03 Matthew Golden, WR, Green Bay Packers
The Packers have a lot of solid receivers; however, they still felt the need to take Matthew Golden in the first round. Additionally, Golden really broke out at Texas this past season, showing off his good speed. Although being a dominant player from day one is likely not in the cards, Golden could ultimately end up being the top wide receiver in Green Bay.
2.04 Cam Skattebo, RB, New York Giants
It is no secret that the running back class this year was deep. Consequently, that allowed Cam Skattebo to fall to the early fourth round to the New York Giants. Moreover, Skattebo isn’t afraid to run through a defender to get extra yards. Therefore, he will be the perfect early down back in a young and exciting Giants offense.
2.05 Jayden Higgins, WR, Houston Texans
Jayden Higgins is a big body receiver with top-end speed. Furthermore, Nico Collins is the undisputed alpha on the Houston Texans; however, after him, there are a lot of targets available in the Texans’ passing game. In contrast, while Higgins has a different skillset than Tank Dell and Stefon Diggs, we saw the numbers those two could put up in the Texans’ offense.
2.06 Shedeur Sanders, QB, Cleveland Browns
Despite the massive slide in the 2025 NFL Draft, I still believe Sanders offers a ton of potential upside in dynasty leagues. In a Superflex league, the value that quarterbacks bring can be invaluable. With the top position players already off the board, I don’t mind reaching a bit in a mock draft gamble on some long-term Superflex upside.
2.07 Mason Taylor, TE, New York Jets
This is, undoubtedly, a slam dunk for the Jets, as Mason Taylor could, in fact, be second in targets behind Garrett Wilson. Furthermore, the receiving room, along with the tight-end room, needs pass-catchers for Justin Fields, which, in turn, gives him a nice short-depth target. Additionally, with this being tight end premium and running backs flying off the board, I feel that Taylor has, quite possibly, more upside here than the wide receivers. Consequently, Taylor should be able to put up TE2 numbers here in year one.
2.08 Tre Harris, WR, Los Angeles Chargers
Tre Harris lands on a team with a fairly shallow WR corps; in fact, there is only Ladd McConkey as a truly locked-in starter. Although Harris isn’t as fast or as tall as his main competition, Quentin Johnston, his hands and ball-tracking skills are far superior. Therefore, this should give him the upper hand in eventually winning the WR2 spot.
2.09 Kyle Williams, WR, New England Patriots
Kyle Williams was a riser throughout the draft process; consequently, he ended up getting taken in the third round. Furthermore, his ADP on Sleeper still has him as a third-round rookie pick. However, most rankings now have him inside the top 24 players in superflex. Moreover, he pairs with Drake Maye on an offense that currently has Stefon Diggs as their WR1.
Notably, Diggs is coming off a torn ACL and into his age-32 season. Additionally, that big contract comes with an opt-out in 2026. Ultimately, Williams brings big upside and a potential #1 WR on an offense, tied to a young QB. Therefore, he presents good value in the late 2nd round.
2.10 Dylan Sampson, RB, Cleveland Browns
Despite landing in Cleveland behind Judkins, Sampson is also a very talented prospect. This offense also lacks weapons and has a ton of uncertainty around it regarding the future. In the late second round, I don’t mind taking the second running back for the Browns taken in this draft. Strictly due to the talent that I believe Sampson brings.
2.11 Jaydon Blue, RB, Dallas Cowboys
It really is, after all, picking your poison at this stage of the draft already. Therefore, I’m swinging from the fences with a running back who, notably, landed in the perfect offense that, unfortunately, lacks real playmakers. Specifically, Jaydon Blue isn’t going to be a workhorse back. However, his explosiveness and pass-catching ability are going to stand out in a one-two punch with Javonte Williams.
Furthermore, the Cowboys opted against drafting a running back early and, surprisingly, didn’t draft a wide receiver at all. Consequently, I think Blue will be on the field a lot in his rookie season, catching passes and being lined up in the slot. Ultimately, I’m very happy to grab that upside at the back of the 2nd.
2.12 Jack Bech, WR, Las Vegas Raiders
With the 24th pick in the draft, I’m taking the best available prospect. At this juncture, it’s Jack Bech. Although Bech lacks in speed and separation, he makes up for it with his ability to catch in tight spaces. Specifically, he uses his body to shield defenders and breaks tackles with his physicality.
In many ways, he gives me some of the traits that Mike Evans has demonstrated over his years in the NFL. Furthermore, he is NOT Quentin Johnston!
Round 3
3.01 Jaylin Noel, WR, Houston Texans
Jaylin Noel has been a target of mine all off-season. In fact, he’s a fast, sharp route runner who consistently separates and wins off the line. Moreover, with sticky hands and great ball tracking, he adjusts well to off-target throws and rarely drops passes. Although he may sit behind Christian Kirk as a rookie, he’s nevertheless a reliable WR3 or flex with WR2 upside and long-term value.
3.02 Bhayshul Tuten, RB, Jacksonville Jaguars
Pleasantly surprised to land Bhayshul Tuten in the third round. Moreover, he’s an explosive back that goes to a Jaguars team with a wide-open backfield. Therefore, it wouldn’t shock me if Tuten is the RB dynasty managers want to roster most from this team by the end of the season.
3.03 Jalen Milroe, QB, Seattle Seahawks
Jalen Milroe had some issues with his accuracy at Alabama; however, he is a dynamic athlete at the quarterback position. Therefore, he should be used early on as a running quarterback threat while sitting behind Sam Darnold. If he shows what he can do in limited action, he could, in fact, end up pushing for the starting job down the road, especially since Darnold isn’t likely a long-term answer at quarterback. Moreover, if for some reason he doesn’t work out at quarterback, he could ultimately change positions and find a role in the NFL.
3.04 Pat Bryant, WR, Denver Broncos
This Broncos’ wide receiver group has a lot of uncertainty around it. Current WR1 for Denver, Courtland Sutton, turns 30 years old this coming October. Additionally, the future of the rest of the receivers is up in the air. I’ll take Bryant here, who has excellent football IQ and can get himself open well. Notably, he had solid draft capital as he was taken with the 74th overall pick. Bo Nix should also be a solid fantasy football producer for the future as well.
3.05 Tyler Shough, QB, New Orleans Saints
Do I think that Tyler Shough is the long-term answer for the New Orleans Saints at quarterback? No. However, would I be surprised if the Saints drafted their franchise QB in 2026? Not at all.
Nevertheless, for this year, there is uncertainty that Derek Carr will even play a game for the Saints, which makes it a distinct possibility that Shough could start some games this year. Furthermore, the Saints did draft Shough in the 2nd round, and he was the third QB drafted, only behind Ward and Dart. Therefore, I’ll take a chance on a potential starting QB in the middle of the third round any day.
3.06 Quinn Ewers, QB, Miami Dolphins
This is solid value late in the draft for a quarterback in Superflex. Ewers has intriguing upside as Tua Tagovailoa has dealt with injuries throughout his entire career. More importantly, the head injuries have been a legitimate threat to his future in the NFL.
3.07 Jalen Royals, WR, Kansas City Chiefs
When it comes to dart throws, why not do it on a wide receiver drafted by the Kansas City Chiefs? Specifically, Patrick Mahomes gets a new weapon in Jalen Royals, who boasts true 4.4 speed and, notably, was second in receiving yards per game in the NCAA. Additionally, he has the versatility to line up both outside and in the slot. Therefore, for him to fall to round four of all places does not add up, especially as Mahomes once again gets a new weapon. In fact, this is a weapon he once lost but now looks to be replaced.
3.08 Devin Neal, RB, New Orleans Saints
Devin Neal’s value took a hit at the combine when he didn’t test the way we had hoped. Consequently, his value took another hit with the lack of draft capital. However, it’s the 3rd round, and you’re looking for an opportunity.
Fortunately, Neal has that in a Saints backfield that has a soon-to-be 30-year-old running back in Alvin Kamara and, additionally, an injury-prone, inefficient back in Kendre Miller in front of him. Thus, he will get his opportunity; let’s just hope he capitalizes on it.
3.09 Terrance Ferguson, TE, Los Angeles Rams
In a TE-Premium format, I’m happy to draft a talented tight end this late in the draft. The Rams have had several options at the tight end position in the past. However, none of them seem to stick. With Cooper Kupp now with the Seahawks, this Rams offense needs more weapons to step up. Ferguson is a solid prospect and could make an impact right away.
3.10 Woody Marks, RB, Houston Texans
Backing up an aging Joe Mixon isn’t a bad place to be with the Texans. Mixon will be 29 to start the 2025 NFL season. However, this backfield could have some opportunities in the future as the only other notable running back is Dameon Pierce.
3.11 Elijah Arroyo, TE, Seattle Seahawks
The Seahawks have been purring about the draft selection of Elijah Arroyo. Moreover, with fantastic Round 2 draft capital and an exciting, explosive upside, I would actually take Arroyo at the back of the 2nd. Therefore, to get him late 3rd is a great value. Additionally, with Noah Fant on an expiring contract at the end of the 2025 season, it feels like the best time to invest in Arroyo, who has the ceiling of a top 10 dynasty TE if he can stay healthy.
3.12 Harold Fannin, TE, Cleveland Browns
With the last pick in the third round, some of my primary targets, Terrance Ferguson and Elijah Arroyo, were selected ahead of me. Therefore, I had to decide between Elic Ayonmanor and Harold Fannin. Both are rebuilding offenses.
Consequently, I went with the player with the higher draft capital, Fannin. In 2024 at Bowling Green, Fannin had a fantastic 117 receptions for 1,555 yards and 10 touchdowns. Indeed, those numbers are outstanding for a player who saw his draft status drop after subpar testing at the combine.
Round 4
4.01 Elic Ayomanor, WR, Tennessee Titans
I was high on Elic Ayomanor pre-draft, taking him in the late second round of mocks. However, his NFL Draft slide makes him my biggest faller. Indeed, he’s shown flashes of Amari Cooper or Rashee Rice, but he could just as easily end up like Terrace Marshall. Furthermore, he has strong ball tracking, clean releases, and the ability to make tough catches in traffic. Ultimately, with the talent to outproduce his draft slot, he’s still worth a late rookie pick with long-term upside.
4.02 Jarquez Hunter, RB, Los Angeles Rams
Jarquez Hunter has the opportunity to secure the backup role in LA after receiving solid draft capital. Furthermore, with an athletic, three-down skillset could put himself in a position to make a serious dent in Kyren Williams‘ playing time by 2026. Ultimately, I’d feel comfortable taking him at the 2/3 turn and am thrilled with this value.
4.03 Brashard Smith, RB, Kansas City Chiefs
Brashard Smith, a former receiver who played running back at SMU last season, could find a niche with the Chiefs. Although several running backs will likely see more playing time initially, Smith’s receiving skills could give him an edge in securing a roster spot.
4.04 Isaac TeSlaa, WR, Detroit Lions
Taken in the 3rd round of the 2025 NFL Draft, TeSlaa lands in a solid spot with the Detroit Lions. This high-powered offense has a lot of mouths to feed. However, this could be a decent landing spot in the future, depending on what happens with Jameson Williams and the WR3 role behind Amon-Ra St. Brown.
4.05 Jordan James, RB, San Francisco 49ers
I’ve stated publicly that I’d prefer a bag of salt & vinegar chips or a Kit Kat bar to a fourth-round draft pick. However, since I had to make a selection, I opted for upside potential. Therefore, why not choose a running back drafted by the San Francisco 49ers? The Niners consistently unearth productive late-round or undrafted backs who become starters—think Trey Sermon, Jordan Mason, Elijah Mitchell, or Isaac Guerendo.
4.06 Ollie Gordon, RB, Miami Dolphins
Gordon is a nice prospect, despite landing in a crowded backfield behind the explosive De’Von Achane and Jaylen Wright. However, the RB2 spot could be up for grabs. Additionally, Achane is more of the pass-catching back on this offense. Gordon could offer some intriguing upside as someone who could earn early-down work for the Dolphins offense.
4.07 Kalel Mullings, RB, Tennessee Titans
I wasn’t surprised to see the Michigan back fall, but Kalel Mullings seems a nice addition to the Tennessee Titans’ offense. Although they signed Tony Pollard last offseason and still have Tyjae Spears—a player many in the dynasty community love (though I’m not one of them)—I see Mullings challenging Spears for the RB2 spot behind Pollard.
Pollard missed some time last season, and Mullings’ bruising style could provide a much-needed breather for him. Furthermore, Mullings’ explosive lateral agility and excellent contact balance will help the Titans’ offense gain those crucial one or two yards, and once he gets into the open field, he’s very difficult to catch.
4.08 Savion Williams, WR, Green Bay Packers
Truly, in the 4th round of a rookie draft, you are throwing darts. While looking at my options, I had a few 5th and 6th-round future practice squad running backs. Or a Day 2 wide receiver with a good quarterback and a lackluster receiving corps in front of him. The choice was easy.
4.09 DJ Giddens, RB, Indianapolis Colts
Although DJ Giddens is a talented back, he would be much higher on boards with the right landing spot. Unfortunately, he landed behind Jonathan Taylor. While this is more of a high-value handcuff situation, Giddens could see a value spike if something were to happen to Taylor.
4.10 Kyle Monangai, RB, Chicago Bears
This late in the draft, I don’t mind taking a 7th-round running back here. D’Andre Swift is still fairly young at 26 years old, but he’s dealt with some injuries throughout his career. Roschon Johnson is the only other threat on this offense, and he’s been good at times when filling in, but not great. Monangai is a multi-year starter in college. His excellent pass protection skills could earn him some playing time early on.
4.11 Tory Horton, WR, Seattle Seahawks
I’m a Tory Horton stan and although I didn’t like him dropping to the back of the 5th Round, I did like his landing spot, a lot. Surely, Seattle has a need for a perimeter weapon and found a real versatile receiver in Horton, who was dominating before injury cut short his 2024 season. Although most of my late RB targets are off the board. Ultimately, I’ll take a swing with my guy who has a rare combination of speed, production, and experience, who can produce right away.
4.12 Will Howard, QB, Pittsburgh Steelers
The final pick in any rookie draft always comes down to the upside. While I don’t think anyone feels like Mason Rudolph or Skylar Thompson are long-term solutions at quarterback for the Steelers, I took National Championship-winning, 4,000-yard passing, and 35 touchdowns throwing Will Howard. Additionally, he may not have the massive upside of some of the quarterbacks selected before him, but Howard gives me Baker Mayfield vibes with his leadership and intangibles.
Trending Now
